The Calistoga City Council convened on March 12, 2024, to discuss the future of sidewalk management in the city, a topic that has resurfaced multiple times over the years. The meeting focused on two primary options for the city regarding sidewalk ownership and maintenance: an air lease option through Caltrans and direct city ownership of the sidewalks.

Council Member Gift opened the discussion by emphasizing that the city’s approach to sidewalks aligns with the general plan established in February 2014. He noted that the issue of sidewalk management is not new, referencing past council discussions dating back to 2009, which highlighted concerns about ADA compliance and liability claims related to sidewalk conditions. Gift pointed out that previous councils had explored options for improving sidewalks but had not followed through with concrete actions.

The council reviewed the current maintenance agreement with Caltrans, which places some responsibilities on local businesses while the city handles trip hazards. However, Gift expressed concerns that the existing maintenance is insufficient for long-term improvements. He urged the council to gather more detailed information on both options before making any decisions.

The air lease option, which has never been implemented in California, would require significant lobbying efforts and could lead to unclear maintenance obligations. In contrast, the city taking over the sidewalks would allow for more direct control and alignment with the city’s beautification goals.

Council Member Nisenberg echoed Gift's concerns, advocating for a careful and deliberate approach to the decision-making process. He highlighted the importance of enhancing sidewalk use for local businesses, suggesting that increased outdoor dining and displays could benefit both the city and its merchants. Nisenberg stressed the need for a plan that reinforces Calistoga's small-town character while ensuring safety and attractiveness.

The council concluded that further investigation into both options is necessary, with a focus on understanding the implications of each choice. No immediate decisions were made, but the discussions underscored the importance of sidewalks in the city’s future planning and community engagement. The council plans to revisit the topic with more comprehensive data to guide their next steps.