Santa Barbara City Council urged to adopt tenant protection ordinance including right to return

During the Santa Barbara City Council meeting on March 4, 2025, a passionate call for tenant protections took center stage, as community members urged the council to adopt a "right to return" clause in the city's tenant protection ordinance. This proposed measure aims to allow tenants to return to their homes at their original rent after renovations, a move supporters argue is essential for maintaining affordable housing and community stability amid rising eviction rates.

Kim Pascag, a vocal advocate, emphasized the urgency of the situation, stating, "The proposed right to return clause... helps maintain affordable housing in our city." She highlighted the adverse effects of evictions on low and moderate-income families, urging the council to act swiftly to address the ongoing crisis. "No more delays," she insisted, referencing similar successful measures in neighboring Goleta.

Cressida Silvers, another speaker, echoed this sentiment, urging the council to prioritize the discussion on the agenda. "Local families face so many escalating stresses... please don't waste any time in moving this item forward," she implored, reflecting the concerns of many residents who fear displacement.

However, not all voices were in favor of the proposed ordinance. Michelle Carbone raised concerns about the lack of data supporting claims of mass evictions, arguing that the ordinance could unfairly burden property owners. She cautioned against what she described as an attempt to impose rent control without considering the economic realities faced by landlords.

The meeting also featured personal testimonies from residents like Gina Kiros, who shared her journey from homelessness to housing stability, and Amber Asher, who described ongoing threats to her housing security. Both emphasized the need for stronger protections for tenants to prevent displacement.

As the council deliberates on this critical issue, the voices of tenants and advocates continue to resonate, highlighting the pressing need for policies that safeguard affordable housing and support the community's most vulnerable members. The outcome of this discussion could significantly impact the future of housing stability in Santa Barbara, making it a pivotal moment for local governance.