The Calistoga City Council meeting on December 19, 2023, sparked intense discussions surrounding the appointment of new members to key committees, particularly the Housing Advisory Committee and the Planning Commission. Mayor Gitt proposed a slate of appointments that would replace several incumbents, igniting concerns among council members about the potential impact on ongoing housing initiatives.

The mayor's nominations included Gwen Becker and Jean Gorman for the Housing Advisory Committee, Sean Burge and Jeremy Grove for the Green Committee, and Susan Schmeiderer, Ismael Ackman, and Aaron Heath for the Active Transportation Committee. However, the most contentious point arose regarding the Planning Commission, where the proposed changes would replace experienced members, including Tim Wilkes, who has been instrumental in housing discussions.

Council members voiced strong opposition to the sweeping changes. Mayor Gitt emphasized the importance of continuity in the Housing Advisory Committee, arguing that losing experienced members could hinder the implementation of the housing element of the General Plan, which is mandated to be updated every eight years. "To lose both Lana and Laurel would be a detriment to our community," Gitt stated, highlighting the critical nature of their work on affordable housing.

Vice Mayor Lopez Ortega echoed these sentiments, advocating for a more gradual approach to change. "Drastic change will be a disaster," she warned, suggesting that maintaining some incumbents could provide necessary mentorship for new appointees. Other council members, including Cooper and Giff, reinforced the need for continuity and expertise, particularly in light of the city's housing challenges.

Despite the push for new perspectives and broader community involvement, the council ultimately recognized the value of experienced members in guiding critical initiatives. The meeting concluded with a call for a balanced approach to appointments, ensuring that both new voices and seasoned experts can contribute to the city's future. As the council navigates these changes, the implications for Calistoga's housing strategy remain a focal point of concern and discussion.