ARB approves Dina Estrada's controversial pergola amid aesthetic concerns in Old East Hill

The City of Pensacola Architectural Board convened on January 16, 2025, to discuss several key projects, including modifications to residential structures and the approval of a new accessory structure.

One of the primary discussions centered around a proposed modification to a residential property, where the applicant sought to replace lower window sashes with siding. The board members engaged in a detailed conversation about the aesthetic implications of this change, ensuring that the new design would maintain the visual integrity of the building. After thorough deliberation, the board unanimously approved the motion to proceed with the modifications.

The second significant item on the agenda involved a request from Dina Estrada for final approval of a newly constructed wood pergola at her property on East Gadsden Street. The pergola, measuring 9 by 6.5 feet and standing 8.5 feet tall, was built without the necessary permits or prior approval from the Architectural Review Board. Estrada explained that she had been misinformed about the permitting process by her contractor.

While the pergola was deemed compliant with zoning regulations, board members expressed concerns regarding the choice of a metal standing seam roof, which some felt detracted from the overall aesthetic of the structure. Suggestions were made to explore alternative roofing options that would better complement the pergola's design. Despite these concerns, the board acknowledged that the pergola was well-received by neighbors, and discussions continued on how to enhance its appearance.

In conclusion, the meeting highlighted the board's commitment to preserving the architectural character of Pensacola while balancing the needs of homeowners. The approval of the window modifications and the ongoing discussions regarding the pergola reflect the board's role in maintaining the city's aesthetic standards. Further steps will be taken to address the concerns raised about the pergola's design before final approval is granted.