Pensacola Historic Board approves storm shutters and window replacements for local residents

The City of Pensacola Architectural Board convened on January 16, 2025, to discuss several applications for modifications within historic districts. The meeting addressed various proposals, focusing on aesthetic compliance and structural integrity in the context of the city's historic preservation efforts.

The first item on the agenda involved a proposal for a pergola in a historic district. Board members discussed the visibility of the structure, noting it would primarily be seen from the parking area. The applicant confirmed that the design met all required setbacks and was code compliant. After deliberation, the board approved the application, emphasizing the importance of aesthetic considerations in historic areas.

Next, the board reviewed a request from Nancy Fetterman to enclose an existing carport at 514 East Government Street to create a garage. This proposal had faced previous rejections due to concerns about its impact on the district's character. The applicant presented a new design featuring a shed roof and two door options. Board members expressed mixed feelings but ultimately approved the design, recognizing the unique circumstances of the non-contributing structure.

The third item involved exterior alterations at 529 East Government Street, where the applicant sought to replace windows and install a tankless water heater. The contractor explained that the changes were necessary for functionality and efficiency. The board approved the alterations, noting the importance of maintaining the historic character while allowing for modern updates.

The meeting continued with a proposal for storm shutters at 14 East Gonzales Street. The applicant, Melanie Nichols, highlighted the historical significance of shutters on the property and the need for storm protection. The board supported the installation of bifold colonial shutters, with a suggestion to consider a color that would complement the existing structure.

Finally, the board addressed a window replacement request at 210 South Alcony Street. The applicants aimed to replace rotted windows with new Andersen Series 400 windows while adding a 12-inch overhang to protect against future water damage. Board members discussed the potential effectiveness of the overhang and the importance of maintaining the original window styles. The proposal was approved, with a focus on ensuring the new installations matched the historic aesthetic.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the board's commitment to balancing modern needs with the preservation of Pensacola's historic character. Each application was carefully considered, reflecting the board's dedication to maintaining the integrity of the city's architectural heritage while accommodating necessary updates.