In a spirited meeting on December 9, 2024, the Huntington City Council faced a pivotal decision regarding a petition from the Huntington Realty Corporation to rezone three parcels on the 1500 Block of Ninth Avenue from a two-family residential district to a neighborhood commercial district (C-1). This change, which would allow for higher density commercial development, sparked a lively debate among council members and community members alike.

The Planning Commission had previously voted unanimously in favor of the rezoning, citing alignment with the city’s 2025 comprehensive plan. However, concerns were raised during the council meeting about the potential impact on the neighborhood, particularly from residents who felt left in the dark about future developments. One council member expressed apprehension, questioning the rationale behind changing the zoning without clear plans from the developers. “If you don’t have any idea what you’re gonna do, why change the zoning?” they asked, highlighting the anxiety of nearby homeowners who have invested in their properties.

Public comments reflected a mix of support and opposition. Former city councilwoman Sandra Clements, a long-time resident of the area, voiced her disappointment over the proposal. She emphasized the importance of maintaining the residential character of the neighborhood, arguing that businesses could bring unwanted noise and traffic. “Can you imagine voting to put a business beside someone’s home?” she questioned, urging the council to consider the long-term implications for families looking to build homes in the area.

On the other side, David Michael, the executive director of Habitat for Humanity, spoke in favor of the rezoning, noting the positive transformation of nearby blocks through their housing initiatives. He expressed concern that without knowing the intended use of the rezoned land, potential homeowners might be deterred from building in the area. “It would surely be nice to know that prior to breaking ground,” he said, advocating for a balance between development and community needs.

Sam St. Clair, president of Huntington Realty Corporation, defended the petition, arguing that the lots have been vacant for decades and that commercial development could revitalize the area. He assured the council that any future projects would be considerate of the neighborhood’s character, stating, “I’m not going to destroy it. I’m a builder.”

As the discussion unfolded, council members weighed the benefits of encouraging neighborhood commercial development against the need to protect residential spaces. Council member Mount highlighted the advantages of C-1 zoning, which promotes walkability and mixed-use spaces, suggesting that it could enhance the community’s livability.

The meeting concluded with a sense of urgency as the council prepared to vote on the rezoning. The outcome will not only shape the future of Ninth Avenue but also reflect the city’s commitment to balancing development with the needs of its residents. As Huntington continues to evolve, the voices of its community members remain crucial in guiding its growth.