Mayor Borer updates on West Haven MARB police pension negotiations ahead of March 21 meeting

During the recent City Council meeting held on March 10, 2025, in West Haven, Connecticut, significant discussions centered around the city's ongoing relationship with the Municipal Accountability Review Board (MARB) and the unresolved issue of the police pension. The meeting highlighted the city's progress in meeting the criteria for exiting MARB oversight, yet it also underscored the challenges that remain, particularly regarding the police pension plan.

Mayor Nancy Borer provided an update on the MARB's criteria for the city's release from oversight, noting that West Haven has successfully met all but one requirement. The city has maintained a positive financial standing, with no deficits, good audit results, and a solid credit rating. However, a new criterion introduced in May 2024, which pertains to "unsound financial practices," remains undefined, creating uncertainty for the city. The mayor expressed frustration over the lack of clarity from MARB on this issue, emphasizing that the city's financial practices have been sound.

The focal point of the discussion was the police pension, which has become a contentious issue. The MARB is scheduled to meet on March 21, 2025, in an executive session to specifically address the status of the police pension and its potential impact on the city's release from MARB oversight. The mayor indicated that if the pension issue is tied to the city's release, it could lead to legal proceedings, with court dates not expected until January 2026.

Councilman Vargo raised questions about whether the concerns stemmed from the unresolved pension issue or the structure of the proposed pension plan. Mayor Borer clarified that the MARB has expressed issues with the pension's structure, which had previously been agreed upon by the police union and the city. The lack of response from MARB regarding the pension proposal has led to a court case, further complicating the situation.

Despite efforts to mediate the pension discussions, progress has been slow. The mayor noted that while there was initial movement towards resolution, subsequent meetings have faced delays due to requests for additional information from the state. This ongoing stalemate has left the city in a challenging position, as it seeks to move forward while navigating the complexities of the pension negotiations.

In conclusion, the City Council meeting underscored the city's achievements in financial management while also revealing the significant hurdles that remain, particularly concerning the police pension. As the March 21 meeting approaches, the outcome could have lasting implications for West Haven's financial autonomy and governance. The city remains hopeful for a resolution that will allow it to exit MARB oversight and continue its progress towards stability and growth.