In the heart of Lock Haven, a spirited discussion unfolded at the city council meeting on November 25, 2024, as community members voiced their concerns and aspirations regarding the display of a nativity scene in Triangle Park. The atmosphere was charged with a mix of passion and purpose, as local leaders and residents navigated the complexities of community traditions and public space usage.

Melissa Dally, the manager of Downtown Lock Haven, took the floor to clarify misconceptions surrounding the nativity display. She emphasized that Downtown Lock Haven, a private organization, was not responsible for permitting the nativity scene, which had been set up by the Clinton County Ministerium without a formal request to the city. Dally explained that her organization had submitted its own beautification project for the holiday season, and the nativity did not fall under their jurisdiction or insurance, as it was not their property.

The conversation took a turn as Dally suggested alternative locations for the nativity, including St. Paul's Church, and proposed the idea of a live nativity to attract more visitors. She shared her vision for a Gingerbread Village, inspired by successful holiday attractions in nearby towns, aiming to enhance foot traffic and support local businesses.

Pastor Joyce Buckner, secretary of the Clinton County Ministerium, responded to Dally's comments, denying any harassment claims and reiterating that the nativity was a community-funded project, intended to symbolize hope and joy during the Christmas season. Buckner expressed disappointment over the lack of direct communication regarding the nativity's placement and the confusion surrounding its future.

Reverend Gary Shumway, president of the Ministerium, added context by explaining that the nativity was a community initiative, funded entirely by donations from local churches and individuals. He highlighted the importance of the nativity's visibility in Triangle Park, a location chosen to spread a message of peace and hope.

As the meeting progressed, the council members listened intently, weighing the community's sentiments against the backdrop of city regulations and public space management. The discussions underscored the delicate balance between tradition and governance, as residents sought to preserve their holiday customs while navigating the complexities of city policies.

The outcome of this meeting remains to be seen, but it has sparked a broader conversation about community engagement, the role of public spaces, and the importance of clear communication among local organizations. As Lock Haven prepares for the holiday season, the future of the nativity scene and the vision for a vibrant downtown continue to hang in the balance, reflecting the hopes and aspirations of its residents.