Tensions flared at the Lock Haven City Council meeting on December 11, 2023, as Matt Rogers, treasurer of Hope Host Company No. 2, challenged statements made by William Bailey of Citizens Host Company regarding the Fire Advisory Board. Rogers asserted that Bailey misrepresented the board's position, claiming he spoke solely for his company rather than the collective interests of the advisory board.

Rogers emphasized that the advisory board had previously met to discuss concerns from all three fire companies, and that Bailey's comments about the proposed ordinance were not reflective of the board's consensus. He clarified that the ordinance allows each fire company to maintain its internal structure, including the election of officers, and that the proposed changes would not hinder their operations.

A key point of contention was Bailey's assertion that the ordinance would create a voting imbalance on the advisory board. Rogers countered that each company would have equal representation, with the department chief serving as a neutral party focused on the city's best interests. He also addressed Bailey's concerns about the inclusion of paid drivers on the advisory board, stating that this issue had not been formally discussed or voted on.

The proposed ordinance, which includes a non-rotating department chief and two district chiefs, aims to streamline command during incidents. Rogers noted that the majority of the advisory board supported this structure, which is designed to enhance operational efficiency.

As the meeting concluded, Rogers reiterated the importance of accurate representation and communication within the fire service, urging that discussions should occur within the advisory board rather than at council meetings. The outcome of these discussions could significantly impact the future structure and governance of Lock Haven's fire services.