Maryland Senate passes Bill 586 affirming Methodist Church asset ownership

On March 13, 2025, the Maryland Legislature introduced Senate Bill 586, a significant piece of legislation that aims to clarify the ownership and management of assets held by various Methodist churches in the state. This bill is particularly relevant as it addresses the ongoing tensions within the United Methodist Church (UMC) regarding property rights and denominational affiliation.

The core purpose of Senate Bill 586 is to ensure that all assets owned by any Methodist church—whether they are incorporated, unincorporated, or even abandoned—are held in trust for the United Methodist Church. This includes churches that were formerly part of the Methodist Episcopal Church, the Methodist Protestant Church, and other related denominations. The bill stipulates that these assets are subject to the discipline and ministerial appointments of the UMC, as determined by its general conference.

One of the notable provisions of the bill is its assertion that the absence of a trust clause in any deed executed before June 1, 1953, does not exempt local churches from their connectional responsibilities to the UMC. This means that even if historical documents do not explicitly state a trust, local congregations are still bound to the UMC's governance and practices if their actions indicate such a connection.

The introduction of this bill has sparked considerable debate among lawmakers and community members. Supporters argue that it reinforces the unity and governance of the UMC, ensuring that local churches remain accountable to the broader denomination. However, opponents raise concerns about potential overreach, fearing that it may infringe on the autonomy of local congregations, especially those considering disaffiliation from the UMC amid ongoing theological disputes.

The implications of Senate Bill 586 extend beyond legal technicalities; they touch on the social fabric of communities where these churches operate. As many congregations grapple with identity and affiliation issues, the bill could influence decisions about church governance and community engagement. Experts suggest that the bill may lead to increased tensions within congregations, particularly those that are divided over their future with the UMC.

As the bill moves forward, it is set to take effect on October 1, 2025, pending further discussions and potential amendments. The outcome of this legislation could reshape the landscape of Methodist churches in Maryland, impacting not only their governance but also their role within the community. Residents and church members alike will be watching closely as the legislative process unfolds, eager to understand how these decisions will affect their local congregations and the broader Methodist community.