Traffic Reform Warriors criticize Jersey City public safety under director James Shea

The Jersey City Municipal Council Meeting on March 12, 2025, highlighted pressing concerns regarding public safety and accountability within the city's administration. The discussions were marked by strong sentiments from community members and council members alike, particularly focusing on the performance of public safety leadership.

One of the most significant topics raised was the call for a vote of no confidence in Public Safety Director James Shea. Councilman Gilmore's leadership in this initiative was praised by residents, including James Seymour, who represented the Traffic Reform Warriors. Seymour emphasized that under Shea's leadership, the city has failed to meet critical safety objectives outlined in the Vision Zero Action Plan, which aims to eliminate traffic-related deaths and injuries. He pointed out that while some progress has been made in street design, enforcement of traffic laws remains inadequate, with many commitments unfulfilled after six years. The absence of a fully operational traffic safety unit and insufficient school crossing guards were highlighted as major concerns affecting community safety.

Another speaker, Samuel Ortiz, shared a personal account of a distressing incident where he had to perform CPR on a woman who had collapsed after being struck by a bus. He criticized the delayed response from emergency services, questioning the effectiveness of the 911 dispatch system and the communication issues faced by first responders. Ortiz's experience underscored the urgent need for improved training and resources for public safety personnel, particularly in emergency situations.

Nick Pastula, another community advocate, echoed these sentiments, calling for greater accountability and action from public safety leadership. He represented various advocacy groups focused on pedestrian safety and expressed gratitude to council members who have supported initiatives aimed at improving safety measures in the city.

The meeting concluded with a clear message from the community: there is a pressing need for the city administration to address these longstanding issues. Residents are calling for immediate action to enhance public safety and ensure that city officials are held accountable for their responsibilities. As discussions continue, the council faces the challenge of responding to these concerns effectively and transparently, with the community closely watching for progress.