The Highland Meeting held in Utah on November 16, 2023, featured a significant discussion led by David Pyne regarding the geopolitical tensions surrounding Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan. The meeting focused on the implications of U.S. foreign policy and its potential risks, particularly in relation to nuclear threats from Russia and China.

Pyne began by analyzing Russia's invasion of Ukraine, framing it as an attempt by President Vladimir Putin to reestablish a form of imperial control over former Soviet republics. He expressed surprise at Putin's decision to withdraw troops from certain occupied regions, suggesting this indicated a more rational approach than previously assumed. Pyne argued that the current U.S. policy towards Ukraine is misaligned with American national security interests, particularly the need to avoid nuclear conflict.

He criticized the Biden administration for what he perceives as a provocative stance that could escalate tensions with Russia. Pyne emphasized that the U.S. should prioritize its own security over Ukraine's ambitions, particularly regarding Crimea, which he labeled a "nuclear red line" for Russia. He warned that the rhetoric surrounding the conflict mirrors dangerous historical precedents, likening the current situation to the lead-up to World War II.

Throughout the discussion, Pyne highlighted the advanced military capabilities of Russia and China, asserting that the U.S. is at a disadvantage and should adopt a more cautious foreign policy. He suggested that a defensive strategy could protect U.S. allies while potentially fostering a more amicable relationship with Russia.

The meeting concluded with Pyne advocating for a reassessment of U.S. foreign policy, urging leaders to adopt a more rational and risk-averse approach to international relations. He called for a shift away from policies that provoke adversaries and towards strategies that prioritize American interests and global stability.