Lisa Garcia proposes renovations for historic home at 936 Fair Street

The Historic Zoning Design Review Commission of Franklin convened on March 17, 2025, to discuss significant renovations proposed for a historic property at 936 Fair Street. The meeting highlighted the importance of preserving the character of the neighborhood while allowing for necessary updates to the home, which dates back to 1893 and is recognized as a contributing structure in the Hensheville National Register District.

Lisa Garcia, the applicant, presented plans to repaint the house, including the roof, and replace the existing front yard fencing. The proposed color scheme features a cream body with evergreen fog green trim, while the metal roof will be power washed and repainted in urban bronze. The front yard fencing will be replaced in kind, maintaining the same design and height, while the current chain link fencing on the sides will be replaced with an 8-foot wood fence, consistent with the style of the existing wooden fence on one side of the property.

Emily, a staff member, emphasized the importance of adhering to the guidelines for historic properties, which recommend preserving original materials and designs. The proposed changes, including the restoration of windows and the addition of gas lanterns, align with these guidelines, although the courtyard lantern was deemed inappropriate for the district.

The commission expressed support for the renovations, recognizing the applicant's commitment to maintaining the historical integrity of the property. The discussions underscored the balance between modernization and preservation, a key concern for residents invested in the character of Franklin's historic neighborhoods.

As the meeting concluded, the commission acknowledged the positive impact these renovations could have on the community, enhancing the aesthetic appeal of Fair Street while respecting its historical significance. The next steps will involve finalizing the details of the project in accordance with the guidelines, ensuring that the updates contribute positively to the neighborhood's heritage.