Clearwater residents challenge street vacation amid concerns over Scientology's influence

The Clearwater City Council meeting on March 17, 2025, sparked intense discussions about the future of downtown Clearwater, particularly regarding a proposed street vacation that could facilitate the construction of a new facility by the Church of Scientology. Community members voiced strong opinions, reflecting deep concerns about the impact of Scientology's presence on the city's revitalization efforts.

Several speakers expressed apprehension that granting the street vacation would further entrench Scientology's influence in Clearwater, which many believe has hindered the downtown area's growth. One resident highlighted the numerous empty storefronts and lamented the lack of attractions for visitors, urging the council to reconsider the vacation proposal. "This is just another way to allow Scientologists to keep their stranglehold in our city," they stated, emphasizing the need for a vibrant downtown that benefits all residents.

Mark Bunker, a prominent critic of Scientology, argued that the construction of the proposed L. Ron Hubbard Hall would not only fail to revitalize downtown but could also exacerbate existing issues. He urged the council to hold off on the street vacation until Scientology fulfills its promises regarding downtown development. "The downtown's dead," he remarked, referencing past assurances that new developments would bring significant foot traffic, which have not materialized.

Conversely, supporters of the project argued that the new hall could attract visitors and stimulate economic growth. A local real estate investor pointed out that new construction typically brings jobs and increases property values, suggesting that the hall could have a positive economic impact on the community. "Anytime that you've got an opportunity to put something like this on the map that brings people in from all over the world, it's always good for the community," they stated.

The meeting also touched on the importance of honoring Clearwater's African American history, with a representative from the Clearwater African American Foundation advocating for recognition of significant landmarks in the area. This call for inclusivity in the city's development plans resonated with many attendees, who emphasized the need for a comprehensive approach to revitalization that considers the diverse history and needs of the community.

As the council deliberates on the street vacation, the discussions reflect a broader desire among Clearwater residents for a downtown that is accessible, vibrant, and representative of its diverse population. The outcome of this decision could significantly shape the future of Clearwater, making it essential for the council to weigh the voices of all community members carefully.