Dana Point Council expresses concerns over South Coast AQMD heating rule amendments

The Dana Point City Council convened on March 18, 2025, to discuss a proposed letter of concern regarding the South Coast Air Quality Management District's (SCAQMD) amended rules 11-11 and 11-21, which focus on residential water heaters and space heaters. Public Works Director Mister Killebrew presented the issue, highlighting potential implications for the electrical grid as the state pushes for a transition from gas to electric appliances.

The council considered a draft letter expressing concerns about the feasibility of these rules, particularly regarding the capacity of existing electrical infrastructure to handle increased demand. Killebrew noted that several other cities have also expressed similar concerns.

During the discussion, Council Member Velar questioned the effectiveness of sending such letters, suggesting they may not influence decision-makers. In contrast, Council Member Federico emphasized the importance of voicing concerns during the listening period, pointing out that many homes in Dana Point may require electrical panel upgrades to accommodate new appliances, which could lead to significant delays and complications for residents.

Mayor Pro Tem Gabbard and other council members echoed these sentiments, stressing that the SCAQMD's focus on reducing greenhouse gases must also consider the practical impacts on residents, including the rising costs of housing and the potential for increased regulatory burdens.

Council Member Frost raised concerns about the enforcement of new regulations and the potential for unpermitted installations if residents face long wait times for permits. The council discussed the availability of federal and state subsidies for homeowners, but Federico noted that many residents might not qualify for assistance, particularly renters who could bear the financial burden of increased costs.

The council ultimately expressed unanimous support for sending the letter of concern, aiming to ensure that the SCAQMD considers the practical implications of its proposed rules before implementation. The meeting concluded with a commitment to follow up on the issue and advocate for a balanced approach to environmental regulations that considers the needs of local residents.