Mark Higgins presents family renovation plans for historic Ann Arbor home

The Ann Arbor Historic District Commission meeting on March 13, 2025, featured a compelling discussion about a proposed renovation project that aims to preserve the historic integrity of a home while accommodating a growing family. The project, presented by Chuck Boltman on behalf of homeowners Mark and Becky Higgins, seeks to transform a house that has faced years of neglect into a vibrant family residence.

Mark Higgins, who joined the meeting via phone from California, expressed his excitement about moving back to Ann Arbor with his wife and their young daughter. He emphasized their desire to create a family home in the Old West Side neighborhood, where they have deep connections. "We want our kids to grow up around their aunts, uncles, and cousins," he stated, highlighting the personal significance of the project.

The proposal includes the construction of an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) for Becky's mother, allowing for multigenerational living. Higgins praised Boltman’s expertise in historic preservation, noting that his work aligns with the values of the historic society. However, the commission raised concerns about the dormer design, which some members felt did not match the existing house's character.

Boltman addressed these concerns, explaining that the house had been in a state of disrepair for over a decade and was at risk of further decline. He argued that the renovation is essential not only for the family's needs but also for the preservation of the neighborhood's historic fabric. "One of the incumbent tasks of the historic district commission is to balance what is old with how we move into the future," he said, advocating for the necessary updates to meet modern building codes.

The commission's deliberations highlighted the ongoing challenge of maintaining historical aesthetics while accommodating contemporary living requirements. As the Higgins family awaits a decision, their project stands as a testament to the potential for historic homes to evolve and thrive in a modern context.