Pennsylvania third class cities explore government reform amid financial challenges

In a recent work session held on March 18, 2025, the City of Bradford's government officials engaged in critical discussions regarding the potential transition to a Home Rule Charter. This meeting highlighted the challenges and opportunities facing third-class cities in Pennsylvania, particularly in light of changing economic conditions and governance structures.

One of the primary concerns raised was the dwindling number of third-class cities that maintain a commission form of government. Officials noted that many cities are now exploring alternative governance models to ensure their survival. The discussion emphasized the urgency of adapting to economic pressures, particularly those exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, which has led some businesses to adopt permanent telework policies. This shift could significantly impact city revenues, with some municipalities facing potential losses in the millions.

The conversation also touched on the importance of transparency and community engagement in the charter change process. Officials stressed that successful transitions often hinge on educating the public about the benefits of a Home Rule Charter. They noted that when communities are well-informed and supportive, the likelihood of a favorable outcome increases dramatically. Recent data indicated that nearly 90% of similar initiatives in the past five years have been successful, largely due to effective communication and community buy-in.

Additionally, the meeting addressed procedural aspects of the charter change, including the requirement for candidates to gather a minimum of 100 signatures to appear on the ballot. This process is nonpartisan, allowing any registered voter to participate in supporting candidates for the commission.

As Bradford considers this significant shift in governance, the discussions from the work session underscore the need for proactive measures to engage the community and ensure that the transition aligns with the city's long-term goals. The next steps will likely involve further public education efforts and the establishment of a clear timeline for the charter change process, as officials aim to navigate the complexities of local governance in a rapidly evolving landscape.