Provo City Council members engaged in a heated debate over the future of Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) during their meeting on November 19, 2024. The discussion centered around a proposed repeal of the special use permit process that allows homeowners to apply for ADUs, a move that some council members argue could negatively impact housing availability in the city.

Councillor George expressed strong opposition to the repeal, citing a lack of evidence that the current system has led to increased violations. He argued that the demand for housing in Provo outpaces supply, and that removing legal pathways for ADUs would exacerbate the issue. "Making ADUs illegal has not been working," he stated, urging his colleagues to reconsider the repeal as it contradicts the planning commission's unanimous recommendation and could set a troubling precedent with state legislators.

Councillor Holborn echoed these sentiments, sharing a story about a single mother who hesitated to apply for an ADU due to uncertainty about the council's decision. Holborn emphasized the importance of maintaining a pathway for those in need, particularly during challenging times. "It feels like we're on the wrong side of this issue," he said, highlighting the limited number of applications processed in recent years and the burdensome costs associated with rezoning.

In contrast, Councillor Whipple raised concerns about the effectiveness of the current ADU process, noting that some neighborhoods have used it to create hostility towards potential renters. He suggested that while the special use permit process has its flaws, it should not be revoked without a better alternative in place. "I would rather keep it as an option than to completely remove this from the table," he stated.

The council ultimately decided to postpone the discussion for two weeks, allowing time for further consideration and potential amendments. This decision reflects the ongoing tension between the desire for increased housing options and the need for neighborhood input and control over local development.

As the council prepares to revisit the issue, the future of ADUs in Provo remains uncertain, with many residents and council members advocating for a balanced approach that addresses both housing needs and community concerns.