Planning Board considers tree removal for parking project compromise

A significant discussion unfolded at the Saratoga Springs Planning Board meeting on March 20, 2025, focusing on a proposed compromise regarding tree removal and replacement in a development project. The board addressed concerns about the removal of a split-trunk tree, which, while not ideal, raised questions about its future viability.

The developer expressed a willingness to compromise, acknowledging the board's previous approvals and the need for additional off-street parking. They proposed replacing the removed tree with larger, more substantial trees, suggesting a shift from the standard two-and-a-half-inch caliper trees to three or three-and-a-half-inch caliper trees. This change aims to enhance the landscaping while addressing the board's concerns about the quality of tree plantings, which have sometimes fallen short of specifications.

Board members voiced their understanding of the developer's position, recognizing the financial implications of tree removal and replacement. The developer noted that the cost of removing the tree alone is approximately $1,500, and they are committed to ensuring that any new trees meet city codes.

The discussion highlighted the balance between development needs and environmental considerations, with board members advocating for a solution that maintains the aesthetic integrity of the area while accommodating necessary project adjustments. As the planning process continues, the board will further evaluate the proposed tree replacements and their impact on the overall project.