E Ariana seeks approval for sand mining rezoning in Southwest Florida

In the heart of Hendry County, a significant discussion unfolded at the Board of County Commissioners meeting on December 10, 2024, as community members and officials gathered to address a proposed sand mining operation. The atmosphere was charged with concern, particularly from local residents who voiced their apprehensions about the long-term impacts of such an endeavor on their community.

Richard Aiken, an attorney representing E. Ariana, the applicant for the sand mine, presented the case for rezoning a 1,330-acre site located on Sam Jones Trail. The proposal aims to transition the land from agricultural use to a Planned Unit Development (PUD) to facilitate sand mining operations. Aiken emphasized that the company, a family-owned business with over 70 years of experience, has operated multiple mines in Florida and is committed to adhering to all 45 conditions outlined in the staff report.

The proposed site is strategically located near the Montura Ranch Estates subdivision, raising concerns among residents about potential environmental and quality-of-life impacts. Aiken acknowledged these worries, stating that the company had engaged with the community to address their concerns, which led to modifications in the application.

Laura DeJean, a principal planner with Johnson Engineering, elaborated on the project’s planning aspects, highlighting that a significant portion of the site would remain undeveloped. The mining activities are planned to occur in phases over the next 20 years, with extensive buffering measures to mitigate noise and dust. DeJean assured the commissioners that the operation would include a 300-foot setback from the main road and a robust landscaping plan to enhance the visual appeal and reduce environmental impact.

Despite the assurances from the applicant, local residents remained skeptical. Many expressed fears that the mining operation could lead to unforeseen consequences, echoing sentiments that the community does not want such an operation in their midst. The meeting underscored a critical juncture for Hendry County, balancing economic development with community concerns about sustainability and quality of life.

As the discussion concluded, the board faced the challenging task of weighing the potential benefits of the sand mine against the voiced apprehensions of the community. The outcome of this proposal could shape the future of Hendry County, making it a pivotal moment for both local governance and community engagement.