Oak Creek council votes on comprehensive plan amendment for Buc-ee's development

A significant policy shift took place at the Oak Creek Common Council meeting on March 18, 2025, as officials voted to amend the city’s comprehensive plan, changing the land use designation from Business Park to Commercial for a key property. This decision, which passed with a majority vote, is poised to pave the way for the development of a Buc-ee's travel center, a highly anticipated project that has sparked both excitement and concern among local residents.

During the meeting, city officials discussed the implications of the proposed Buc-ee's location, particularly its proximity to residential neighborhoods. Concerns were raised about potential environmental impacts, traffic congestion, and the overall compatibility of a large commercial establishment within a primarily residential area. Alderman Ritz acknowledged the community's apprehensions, emphasizing the importance of thorough research and public dialogue in the decision-making process.

The council's deliberations highlighted the recent opening of the Elm Road exit as a significant factor in reconsidering the land's use. Alderman Greg noted that this change in infrastructure could transform the area into a more viable commercial hub, justifying the amendment to the comprehensive plan. However, some council members expressed reservations, arguing that the proposed use does not align with the original vision for the site as a Business Park, which could accommodate a variety of industrial uses.

In a bid to ensure transparency, the city expanded its notification process, reaching out to residents beyond the typical 300-foot radius to engage a broader audience in the discussion. This effort aimed to address community concerns and foster a more inclusive dialogue about the potential impacts of the Buc-ee's development.

As the council moves forward, the decision to rezone the property marks a pivotal moment for Oak Creek, balancing the need for economic development with the interests of local residents. The anticipated Buc-ee's project is expected to generate significant tax revenue and create jobs, but its success will depend on how well it integrates into the existing community fabric. The council's commitment to ongoing public engagement will be crucial as the project progresses through subsequent planning stages.