Geneva Historic District plans major house renovation and garage addition

A significant proposal for the Geneva Historic District took center stage at the Historic Preservation Commission meeting on March 18, 2024. The applicant is seeking approval for a comprehensive demolition, addition, and rehabilitation plan that aims to enhance a historic home while preserving its architectural integrity.

The project involves demolishing a non-historic detached garage and replacing it with an attached garage that includes living space above. Additionally, the primary entrance of the house will be relocated to face North Fifth Street, and a two-story addition is planned for the north side of the building. This expansion is designed to create more living space for the family while maintaining the neighborhood's aesthetic.

Importantly, the Illinois State Historic Preservation Office has already approved the project, confirming that it aligns with the Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation. These standards are crucial as they guide the Historic Preservation Commission in reviewing permits, ensuring that any modifications respect the historical significance of the structures involved.

Matthew Mayer, the owner of the property at 501 Hamilton, presented the latest updates on the plans and expressed readiness to address any questions from the commission. The discussions highlighted the balance between modern living needs and the preservation of Geneva's historical character, marking a pivotal moment for the community's architectural landscape. As the project moves forward, it promises to enhance both the functionality of the home and the overall charm of the historic district.