On March 25, 2025, Indiana House Legislation introduced House Bill 1471, a significant piece of legislation aimed at reforming the management of Giglio lists, which are used to track law enforcement officers whose credibility may be questioned in court. The bill seeks to establish clearer procedures for the placement and reconsideration of officers' names on these lists, addressing concerns about transparency and fairness in the criminal justice system.

The primary provisions of House Bill 1471 include a structured process for prosecuting attorneys to either approve or deny requests for reconsideration of an officer's status on the Giglio list. If an officer fails to comply with the reconsideration requirements, their name will remain on the list. Additionally, the bill allows prosecuting attorneys to remove an officer's name if new, material information comes to light that was not available during the initial determination.

Another key aspect of the bill mandates that prosecuting attorneys who maintain a Giglio list must adopt policies outlining the procedures for placing names on the list, the reconsideration process, and notice requirements. Furthermore, the bill stipulates that law enforcement agencies cannot demote, suspend, or terminate officers solely based on their inclusion on a Giglio list, unless the underlying facts warrant disciplinary action.

Debate surrounding House Bill 1471 has highlighted concerns about the balance between accountability and the rights of law enforcement officers. Proponents argue that the bill enhances transparency and protects the integrity of the judicial process, while opponents raise concerns about potential misuse of the Giglio list and the implications for officers' careers.

The implications of House Bill 1471 are significant, as it seeks to address longstanding issues related to the treatment of law enforcement officers and the management of their credibility in legal proceedings. Experts suggest that the bill could lead to more equitable treatment of officers while ensuring that prosecuting attorneys uphold their obligations to disclose relevant information to defense counsel.

As the legislative process continues, the future of House Bill 1471 remains uncertain, with potential amendments and further discussions expected in the coming weeks. The bill's outcome could set a precedent for how Giglio lists are managed in Indiana and potentially influence similar reforms in other states.