Gretchen's House seeks plumbing code variances for Ann Arbor childcare center

The Ann Arbor Building Board of Appeals convened on March 20, 2025, to discuss a variance request from Gretchen's House childcare center regarding compliance with the 2021 Michigan Plumbing Code. The meeting focused on the proposed design of toilet facilities intended for young children, which raised significant concerns about safety and privacy standards.

The applicant, Gretchen Preston, presented her case, emphasizing the unique needs of very young children in childcare settings. She argued that the existing code requirements, particularly those concerning water closet enclosures and grab bars, do not adequately consider the practicalities of caring for small children. Preston requested variances to eliminate the need for full-height walls and doors around toilet facilities, as well as the installation of grab bars, which she claimed are not usable by very young children.

During the review, staff members highlighted that the proposed plans did not meet the minimum requirements outlined in the plumbing code. Specifically, they noted that each water closet utilized by the public or employees must occupy a separate compartment with walls or partitions and a door to ensure privacy. The staff recommended denying the variance request, stating that the code provisions were clear and applicable to the situation.

Preston countered by suggesting alternative designs, such as half walls with half doors, which she believes would better serve the needs of children while still providing supervision during handwashing. However, the staff maintained that the proposed conditions did not align with the established standards for restroom facilities.

The meeting concluded with a clear division between the applicant's vision for a child-friendly environment and the regulatory framework designed to ensure safety and privacy. The Board will need to weigh these considerations carefully before making a final decision on the variance request. Further discussions and potential follow-up actions are expected as the Board deliberates on the implications of the proposed changes for childcare facilities in Ann Arbor.