Idaho lawmakers propose new penalties for lewd conduct with minors under 12

A proposed bill aimed at toughening penalties for lewd conduct with minors under 16 sparked intense discussion during the Idaho House Ways and Means meeting on March 7, 2025. Representative Tanner introduced the legislation, which seeks to broaden the definition of lewd conduct and introduce harsher penalties for offenders, particularly those committing heinous crimes against children aged 11 and under.

The bill includes provisions for life sentences with a minimum of 25 years before parole for offenders who meet specific aggravating factors. In extreme cases, where multiple aggravating factors are present, the death penalty could be considered. Tanner expressed strong opinions on the necessity of this legislation, arguing that current laws do not adequately address the severity of these crimes. He referenced a past Supreme Court ruling that deemed the death penalty unconstitutional for certain offenses, asserting that it should be revisited.

The discussion also touched on the bill's coverage of various crimes, including molestation, and the definition of coercion, which some representatives found vague. Concerns were raised about the potential implications for high school students, with one representative questioning whether the bill could inadvertently criminalize typical teenage interactions.

Despite the concerns, Tanner defended the bill, emphasizing that existing laws already provide age limits to prevent misapplication. The committee ultimately moved to introduce the bill, but not without dissent from some members who expressed reservations about the implications of expanding the death penalty.

As the bill progresses, it highlights the ongoing debate in Idaho regarding the balance between protecting children and ensuring fair legal standards. The committee's decision to advance the legislation signals a significant step in addressing serious crimes against minors, with potential ramifications for the state's legal landscape.