Beaufort Historic Review Board discusses building demolition after structural concerns

The City of Beaufort held a meeting on December 11, 2024, to discuss HRB 12-11-24, focusing on the potential demolition of a building deemed structurally unsound. The meeting began with procedural remarks, emphasizing the need for two separate motions regarding the building's fate.

The owner, an architect, addressed the board, clarifying that demolition was not initially intended. After seven months of meetings and assessments, it was only upon hiring contractors that the building's severe structural issues were revealed. The owner expressed a commitment to architectural preservation but highlighted the necessity of prioritizing health and safety due to the building's deteriorating condition, including failing mechanical systems and fire hazards.

Public comments followed, with David Townsend, a local contractor with extensive experience in historic restoration, sharing his insights. He stated that after thorough inspections, he found no evidence suggesting the building predates the early 1950s, arguing that its condition warranted reconsideration of its historical significance.

Maxine Lutz, representing Historic Beaufort, provided a surprising endorsement for the demolition, citing the engineers' findings as justification. This marked a rare instance of support for demolition from a group typically opposed to such actions.

The meeting concluded with no further public comments, and the board prepared to discuss the matter further, indicating a significant decision ahead regarding the building's future. The outcome of this discussion will determine the next steps for the property and its compliance with Beaufort's building codes.