Planning Commission reviews downtown remodel for former Sears building into grocery store

The Santa Maria Planning Commission convened on April 2, 2025, to discuss the proposed remodel of the former Sears building located at 226 East Main Street. The meeting focused on the application for a downtown permit to transform the 114,000 square-foot structure, which has been vacant since its closure in 2020.

Carol Dizonhennie, a staff member, presented the details of the project, emphasizing its significance as it occupies a critical corner in the downtown area. The remodel aims to accommodate an El Super grocery store and up to four smaller retail tenants on the ground floor, with additional larger tenant spaces planned for the second floor. The project also includes improvements to parking and landscaping, enhancing pedestrian access from Main and Miller Streets.

Key features of the proposal include the reorientation of parking spaces for easier access, the addition of dedicated pedestrian walkways compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act, and the relocation of loading docks to better integrate with the mall's operations. The design also incorporates bike parking facilities to promote alternative transportation.

A notable aspect of the application is the request for a public convenience and necessity finding related to alcohol sales. The grocery store seeks a license for off-sale alcohol, which would allow customers to purchase alcohol to take home, with no consumption permitted on-site.

The Planning Commission's review is a crucial step before the application moves to the City Council for final approval. The project is seen as a vital redevelopment effort aimed at revitalizing the downtown area and enhancing local commerce. The commission's decision will play a significant role in shaping the future of this prominent site in Santa Maria.