Historic Landmark Commission recommends demolishing three buildings in Central City District

The Historical Landmark Commission of Salt Lake City convened on April 3, 2025, to discuss the demolition requests for three contributing buildings located within the Central City Local Historic District. The properties under consideration are situated at 652 East 600 South, 664 East 600 South, and 665 East Ely Place. The meeting focused on the implications of these demolitions and the historical significance of the structures involved.

The planning staff presented a thorough analysis of the demolition requests, noting that while the buildings comply with three out of five demolition standards, they do not meet the criteria regarding historic integrity and potential for adaptive reuse. The staff recommended approval for all three demolition requests, citing the deteriorating condition of the buildings and previous approvals for demolition in 2017.

During the meeting, concerns were raised by community members, particularly from Cindy Cromer, who expressed strong opposition to the demolitions. Cromer highlighted the historical value of the structures and referenced past demolitions within the district, arguing that the loss of these buildings would further erode the character of the Central City Historic District. She emphasized the need for careful consideration of the standards for contributing status and urged for documentation of the buildings before any demolition occurs.

The commission members engaged in discussions about the historical context of the buildings, the changes in staff recommendations since 2017, and the potential for new construction on the sites. It was clarified that while the demolition requests were being considered, any new construction plans would need to be submitted and approved separately.

The applicant, represented by architect Jerry Walker and attorney Douglas White, argued that the buildings had significantly deteriorated over the years and that their demolition was necessary for future development. They expressed a commitment to salvage any reusable materials from the structures and highlighted the importance of revitalizing the area surrounding Trolley Square.

The commission ultimately acknowledged the complexities surrounding the demolition requests, including the balance between preserving historical integrity and addressing the realities of urban development. The meeting concluded with no immediate decisions made, as further discussions and considerations are expected in future sessions. The commission will continue to evaluate the implications of these demolitions on the historic district and the community at large.