Half Moon Bay residents criticize new rental program for demonizing landlords

Concerns over a new rental policy dominated the Half Moon Bay City Council meeting on April 1, 2025, as residents voiced strong objections to measures perceived as punitive towards landlords. Critics argue that the proposed program unfairly targets property owners, labeling them as greedy and contributing to a negative atmosphere for those providing rental housing in the community.

One resident passionately expressed that the initiative sends a damaging message, suggesting it demonizes landlords while ignoring the complexities of the rental market. "This program tells citizens that they're bad people," she stated, emphasizing that both landlords and tenants can have their faults. She highlighted that many landlords in Half Moon Bay are local residents who have invested in their properties, not large investors looking to exploit the market.

Another speaker echoed these sentiments, noting that the increased registration fees for rental properties have led some landlords to sell their units rather than comply with the new regulations. "It feels like a money grab by the city," he remarked, indicating that the policy could drive away those willing to provide rental housing.

The discussions raised critical questions about the balance between tenant protections and the rights of landlords, with residents urging the council to reconsider the implications of their approach. As the city grapples with housing challenges, the feedback from the community suggests a need for a more nuanced policy that considers the interests of both parties involved in the rental market. The council's next steps will be crucial in determining the future landscape of housing in Half Moon Bay.