Pelican Watch negotiations yield agreement on live entertainment hours and conditions

In the heart of Fort Myers Beach, the Town Council convened on April 7, 2025, to address a contentious issue that has stirred both excitement and concern among residents and business owners alike. The meeting, held under the warm glow of city hall lights, focused on the proposed regulations for live entertainment and ambient music in local establishments, a topic that has sparked passionate debate within the community.

At the center of the discussion was a proposal to allow live entertainment four days a week, with performances limited to solo or duo acts for three of those days. The fourth day would permit non-musical activities, such as bingo or trivia, but would not allow amplified music. This compromise aimed to balance the interests of local businesses seeking to attract customers with the concerns of residents who worry about noise levels.

Katie Berkey, representing Pelican Watch, emphasized the need for clarity in the regulations, particularly regarding ambient music. While her clients sought to have ambient music permitted daily from noon to 8 PM, the council grappled with the implications of such a provision. The discussions revealed a divide, with some council members advocating for restrictions on ambient music to mitigate potential disturbances.

As the meeting progressed, the specter of litigation loomed large. Berkey noted that her clients were considering legal action if an agreement could not be reached, adding a layer of urgency to the negotiations. Despite the tension, council members expressed a willingness to find common ground, acknowledging the progress made in discussions thus far.

The council ultimately moved to approve the ordinance with specific conditions, including a stipulation that all amplified sound would be managed by property owners and staff, ensuring compliance with existing noise ordinances. The agreement also included a provision for a four-foot fence around entertainment areas, a measure aimed at enhancing safety and managing noise.

As the meeting drew to a close, the council's decision reflected a commitment to fostering a vibrant community atmosphere while addressing the concerns of residents. The outcome of this meeting will likely shape the future of entertainment in Fort Myers Beach, as both business owners and residents navigate the delicate balance between lively gatherings and peaceful living. The council's efforts to mediate these interests signal a proactive approach to community governance, leaving many eager to see how these new regulations will unfold in practice.