Historic Hussey House proposes winter solstice gray for color approval

The Nantucket Historic District Commission made significant strides in preserving the character of the Hussey House, a historic structure dating back to 1795, during their meeting on April 8, 2025. The commission focused on finalizing details for the house's restoration, particularly the color scheme and the addition of shutters.

The proposal included a new roof made of fireproof cedar and a skylight, but the most contentious issue was the trim color. The applicant suggested a shade called "Winter Solstice," a muted gray that has been well-received in other local projects. However, the commission members expressed concerns about the addition of shutters, suggesting that they might detract from the house's rustic charm.

Commissioner Holly highlighted the house's historical significance, noting its simple design and urging for a more natural aesthetic without the shutters. Other members echoed this sentiment, advocating for a minimalist approach that respects the building's Quaker style. The consensus leaned towards approving the color while omitting the shutters, with some members suggesting that if shutters were to be added, they should be simpler and more rustic.

Ultimately, the commission voted to approve the color "Winter Solstice" for the trim, while deferring the decision on shutters until a more fitting design could be proposed. This decision reflects the commission's commitment to maintaining the historical integrity of Nantucket's architectural heritage while allowing for thoughtful updates. The next steps will involve further discussions on the shutter design, ensuring any additions align with the house's historic character.