Westerly Town Council members engaged in a heated discussion on October 28, 2024, regarding the implications of the Wild and Scenic designation for the Pawcatuck River, particularly focusing on the Potter Hill Dam. The council heard from residents concerned about the potential removal of the dam and its impact on local recreation, property values, and the environment.

One resident expressed skepticism about the designation, arguing that it inaccurately portrays the river as "wild" when it has been developed for years. He emphasized that the river's current state, with existing dams, should not be overlooked in discussions about its ecological restoration. He pointed out that while fish ladders could be a solution for fish migration, they could be implemented without drastic changes to the river's structure.

Another speaker, Milo Willets, echoed these sentiments, criticizing what he described as misinformation surrounding the dam's removal. He highlighted that the Potter Hill Dam is the only non-compliant section of the river, while other areas have successfully maintained their dams and implemented effective fish ladders. Willets argued that the removal of the dam would harm local property owners by diminishing water views and recreational access, ultimately lowering property values.

The discussion underscored a broader concern about the balance between environmental initiatives and the needs of local communities. Residents voiced their apprehension about the potential consequences of altering the river's current state, advocating for solutions that would preserve both the ecological integrity of the river and the interests of those who live nearby.

As the council continues to deliberate on this issue, the community remains divided on the best path forward, with many calling for a careful consideration of both environmental goals and local impacts. The outcome of these discussions will likely shape the future of the Pawcatuck River and its surrounding areas.