Cedar Crest homeowners demand clarity on short-term rental parking regulations

The Washoe County Board of County Commissioners meeting on April 8, 2025, focused on the contentious issue of short-term rentals (STRs) and associated parking regulations in Incline Village. The meeting featured passionate public comments from residents, particularly from Matt and Bernadette Castagnola, who have owned their property for over 21 years and expressed concerns about new restrictions impacting their ability to rent and use their property.

The Castagnolas argued that they were not informed about a grandfather clause that could exempt them from new STR regulations, which they believe undermines their rights as long-term property owners. They highlighted their compliance with local laws, including tax payments and adherence to existing rental agreements, and criticized the homeowners association (HOA) for allegedly misrepresenting community sentiments regarding STRs.

A significant point of contention was the parking regulations, which limit the number of vehicles allowed per unit. The Castagnolas, citing their disability needs, requested an additional parking space to accommodate family visits and assistance. They argued that the current restrictions are unreasonable and impede their ability to enjoy their property fully.

Commissioners discussed the complexities of the parking regulations, noting that the code does not currently provide exceptions for individuals with disabilities. Commissioner Garcia suggested exploring a potential accommodation for residents with documented disabilities, which could allow for additional parking privileges under certain conditions.

The board acknowledged the need for further review of the STR ordinance and the parking regulations, particularly in light of the Castagnolas' situation. While some commissioners expressed sympathy for the Castagnolas' plight, others were cautious about setting a precedent that could complicate enforcement of existing regulations.

In conclusion, the board decided to continue discussions on the STR regulations and parking issues, emphasizing the importance of balancing property rights with community regulations. The Castagnolas' case will be revisited as part of ongoing efforts to address the challenges posed by STRs in the area.