Saratoga Design Review Board approves plans for Circular Street home's renovations

The Saratoga Design Review Commission convened on April 9, 2025, to discuss two significant applications that could reshape local architecture and community spaces. The meeting highlighted the balance between preserving historic character and accommodating modern needs.

The first application involved a new construction project at 81 Filus Street. While some members expressed concerns about the building's height and compatibility with neighboring structures, the majority felt it aligned well with the existing streetscape. The commission ultimately approved the plans, including a minor height reduction, signaling a step forward for the project.

The second application focused on 129 Circular Street, where homeowners Peter and Leslie Rubacki proposed modifications to their historic residence and carriage house. The couple aims to enhance the home for their large family while maintaining its historic charm. Key changes include replacing non-historic windows with Marvin windows featuring divided lights, which align with the home's character. The proposed addition of a pantry and modifications to the carriage house doors sparked discussion among commission members, particularly regarding the use of aluminum-clad windows versus traditional wood.

While the commission generally supported the proposed changes, concerns arose about the addition of a new door on the historic facade, which could disrupt the building's symmetry. Suggestions were made to repurpose existing windows for the new door opening, allowing for a solution that respects the building's historic integrity.

The meeting concluded with a consensus to approve the carriage house modifications, contingent on using wood for the windows, while deferring a decision on the side addition until further revisions are presented. This approach reflects the commission's commitment to preserving Saratoga's architectural heritage while accommodating the evolving needs of its residents. As these projects move forward, they will undoubtedly contribute to the ongoing dialogue about the balance between preservation and progress in Saratoga Springs.