Commissioners recommend simplification for new ADU design in Santa Barbara

The Historic Landmarks Commission of Santa Barbara convened on April 9, 2025, to discuss a proposed project that has sparked significant dialogue among commissioners regarding its design and integration with the historic character of the neighborhood. The focus of the meeting was a new Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) and its relationship to the existing main house, which is recognized as a historic structure.

Commissioners expressed a strong consensus on the need for simplification in the design of the ADU. Many voiced concerns that the current plans introduce excessive complexity, particularly in the roof design and overall massing. Commissioner Hansberg emphasized the importance of reducing the number of roof elements and suggested that the garage size could be reconsidered to enhance the project's coherence. He advocated for a more unified appearance, proposing that the ADU should feature a simpler roof style that aligns better with the main house.

The discussion also highlighted the need for the ADU to reflect the architectural language of the main house while maintaining its own identity. Several commissioners, including Lemick and Early, pointed out that the dormers on the ADU might be unnecessary and could detract from the overall aesthetic. They recommended that the design should either echo the main house's style or adopt a more understated vernacular that complements it without direct imitation.

Another significant point raised was the treatment of the front yard. Commissioners noted that the proposed stonework and retaining walls could disrupt the neighborhood's character and suggested exploring simpler landscaping solutions that align with the existing streetscape. The idea of creating a more symmetrical layout around the pool was also discussed, with the aim of enhancing the overall harmony of the property.

In conclusion, the commission's feedback underscored a collective desire for a design that respects the historic context while ensuring that the new construction is both functional and aesthetically pleasing. The project will be revisited in future meetings, with the expectation that the applicant will incorporate the commissioners' suggestions to create a more cohesive and simplified design that honors the historic significance of the main house and the surrounding neighborhood.