Activist threatens civil suit over alleged free speech violations at Michigan meeting

The Alpena City Council meeting on December 16, 2024, featured a significant public comment session that raised concerns about free speech and government accountability. The meeting began with routine administrative matters before transitioning to public input, where a speaker addressed the council regarding the implications of various Supreme Court cases on First Amendment rights.

The speaker referenced multiple legal precedents, including Bethel v. School District, Texas v. Johnson, and Citizens United v. FEC, emphasizing that these cases establish the principle that government officials cannot selectively suppress speech. The speaker asserted that any attempt by officials to limit free expression could lead to personal liability under federal law, specifically citing 18 USC 242 and 42 USC 1983.

The discussion highlighted the speaker's intention to hold local officials accountable for any perceived violations of civil rights, indicating that legal action could be pursued if such issues were not addressed. The speaker also mentioned ongoing lawsuits against the state of Michigan concerning alleged violations of Fourth and Second Amendment rights.

The meeting concluded with the council acknowledging the public's concerns, although no immediate actions or resolutions were proposed in response to the comments made. The council's next steps regarding the issues raised remain to be seen as they continue to navigate the balance between governance and the protection of individual rights.