Clearwater and Dunedin grapple with jurisdiction issues in stormwater management debate

The City of Dunedin's Local Planning Agency meeting on April 10, 2025, highlighted significant concerns regarding jurisdictional complexities and infrastructure costs tied to a proposed annexation. Key discussions centered on the challenges of managing services across multiple jurisdictions, particularly in relation to stormwater management and police protection.

One agency member pointed out the difficulties of enforcing regulations when a site straddles Clearwater and Dunedin, emphasizing that a single jurisdiction would streamline operations and reduce costs for applicants. The conversation underscored the financial impracticality of extending sewer services to newly annexed areas, with one member noting, “the payback is not there” for the minimal property tax revenue expected.

In a related discussion, the agency addressed the status of a new public parking garage. It was revealed that the project is still in the design phase and has not yet undergone the design review process. Once the design is finalized, the city plans to rezone the property to municipal public lands, which would exempt it from a full design review but still allow for some oversight.

The meeting concluded with a motion to accept the proposed ordinance, which passed despite some opposition, reflecting the ongoing debate about the best path forward for Dunedin's growth and infrastructure management. As the city navigates these challenges, the focus remains on ensuring efficient governance and sustainable development.