Care Based Safety advocates for unarmed crisis response in Washtenaw County

The Ann Arbor Human Rights Commission meeting on April 9, 2025, highlighted critical discussions surrounding police interactions with marginalized communities, particularly those experiencing mental health crises. A key focus was the alarming statistics indicating that Black and Hispanic individuals are 50% more likely to experience police use of force, while those with mental illnesses face a tenfold increase in such encounters. This disparity underscores a pressing need for reform in how law enforcement engages with vulnerable populations.

The meeting also addressed the historical mistrust of police, which often discourages individuals from seeking necessary help during crises. This mistrust can lead to a cycle of suffering in silence, where individuals avoid resources that could aid their safety and well-being. The commission emphasized the importance of understanding how systemic issues, such as surveillance and soft policing, contribute to the marginalization of these communities.

A significant point raised was the tragic case of Ora Rosser, who was killed by the Ann Arbor Police Department during a mental health crisis ten years ago. This incident, along with recent events involving youth in crisis, illustrates the urgent need for effective crisis response systems that do not involve police intervention. The commission discussed the work of organizations like Care Based Safety, which advocates for unarmed crisis response teams. However, they noted that current regulations have limited these efforts to areas outside Ann Arbor, highlighting a gap in services that could benefit the community.

The meeting also explored the concept of consent-based responses in crisis situations, stressing the importance of respecting the autonomy of individuals with disabilities. Activists have raised concerns about introducing coercive measures under the guise of support, which could further undermine the dignity of those in crisis.

Looking ahead, the commission identified both forces for and against change in the community. Support for reform includes strong community engagement and existing proposals from organizations like CROWS. However, challenges remain, particularly in working with administration that favors a co-response model involving police. The commission emphasized the need for tangible actions to accompany reformist rhetoric, urging stakeholders to commit to meaningful change.

As discussions continue, the commission remains focused on advocating for a community-centered approach to crisis response, aiming to foster a safer and more supportive environment for all residents of Ann Arbor.