Architecture Board recommends raising roof for 1 story addition at 60 South Drexel

The City of Bexley Architecture Review Board convened on April 10, 2025, to discuss significant architectural modifications proposed for local properties, focusing on enhancing aesthetic appeal and functionality while ensuring community standards are met.

One of the primary discussions centered around a proposed one-story addition to a residence on South Drexel Avenue. The applicant aimed to infuse warmth into the design by selecting a composite finish in lighter tones, such as marshmallow and red cedar, to replace the existing drab gray exterior. The addition features a standing seam metal roof, designed for durability and low maintenance. Board members expressed enthusiasm for the materials chosen, highlighting their potential to complement the existing structure.

However, concerns were raised regarding the massing of the addition. Several board members suggested elevating the roofline by two to three feet to create a more distinct separation between the new addition and the existing garage. This adjustment was seen as a way to enhance the visual appeal and ensure the addition does not blend too seamlessly with the larger structure, which could diminish its presence.

In addition to the roof elevation, board members proposed modifications to a breezeway area, suggesting the incorporation of windows to allow natural light and the creation of a small nook for seating. These changes aim to improve the functionality of the space while also addressing aesthetic concerns.

The board unanimously recommended granting a certificate of appropriateness for the project, contingent upon the elevation of the roofline to differentiate the addition from the existing structure. This decision reflects the board's commitment to maintaining the architectural integrity of Bexley while encouraging thoughtful and modern design solutions.

Another application discussed involved enclosing an existing porch with window walls. The applicant sought to change the previously approved dark color to white, citing a significant cost increase associated with the darker materials. Board members reiterated the importance of maintaining a cohesive aesthetic that complements the home’s existing features, emphasizing that a darker color would enhance the visual appeal by allowing the porch to recede into the background rather than compete with the prominent columns.

The meeting concluded with a consensus on the importance of thoughtful design that respects the character of Bexley’s neighborhoods. The board's recommendations aim to ensure that new constructions and modifications enhance the community's architectural landscape while meeting the needs of homeowners. As the city continues to evolve, these discussions highlight the balance between modern design and historical preservation.