Donald Black presents renovation plans for historic home in Ann Arbor's Old West Side

During the recent Ann Arbor Historic District Commission meeting on April 10, 2025, discussions centered on a proposed renovation project for a historic home located in the Old West Side neighborhood. The applicant, Donald Black, expressed his commitment to restoring the property, highlighting his personal ties to Michigan and his desire to enhance the home’s historical character.

Black's proposal includes replacing existing windows on the back of the house, which he believes will positively contribute to the overall aesthetic. Commission members echoed his sentiments, noting that the changes would add texture and visual appeal without detracting from the home's historic integrity. The discussion also touched on the materials for a new door, with some confusion regarding whether it would be made of metal or polypropylene. Black clarified that while the cylinder would be metal, the door itself could be either material, as they had not yet made a purchase.

A significant point of discussion involved the treatment of two existing windows on the second floor, which are currently in bathrooms. Black explained that while the windows would be insulated and drywalled on the interior for practical reasons, they would maintain their appearance from the outside. This approach aims to preserve the historic look of the house while accommodating modern needs.

The commission also addressed the historical significance of the windows, with Black noting that most of the house's windows are original, except for a couple of front sashes. He mentioned that a restoration expert had assessed the windows and determined that some may not date back to the house's construction in 1883, which adds another layer of complexity to the renovation.

The meeting underscored the commission's ongoing commitment to balancing modern renovations with the preservation of Ann Arbor's rich architectural heritage. As the project moves forward, it will be essential for the commission to ensure that any changes respect the historical context of the neighborhood while meeting the needs of its residents.