Landmarks Commission reviews new event space proposal for historic building

The Manhattan Community Board 2's Landmarks Committee convened on April 10, 2025, to discuss significant renovations and branding proposals for a historic building previously occupied by the New York Women's League for Animals. A key focus of the meeting was the introduction of a new aluminum structure intended to serve as an event space on the terrace, designed to enhance community engagement through presentations and gatherings.

Committee members expressed concerns regarding the preservation of the building's historic fabric, particularly the inlaid signage at the entrance, which is original to the structure. The committee emphasized the importance of maintaining these historical elements, likening their removal to demolishing integral parts of the building. The current tenant's proposal includes cleaning and maintaining the original inlay while replacing a non-original concrete threshold with a more suitable design.

Discussions also highlighted the tenant's willingness to reconsider the dimensions of their proposed signage, which some committee members deemed excessive. The committee noted that the cumulative effect of multiple signs could detract from the building's historic character. In response, the tenant indicated a readiness to adjust their signage plans to minimize visual impact while still achieving their branding goals.

As the meeting concluded, the committee underscored the importance of balancing modern branding needs with the preservation of historical integrity. The next steps will involve further discussions on the mock-up of the proposed screen and continued dialogue about signage dimensions, ensuring that the community's historical legacy remains intact while accommodating contemporary uses.