Palm Coast residents clash over Ralph Carter Park noise and lighting issues

In the heart of Palm Coast, a passionate debate unfolded at the City Council Business Workshop on April 8, 2025, as residents voiced their concerns over the future of Ralph Carter Park. The park, originally designed as a neighborhood retreat, has become a focal point of contention due to its transformation into a sports complex, drawing large crowds and bright lights that disrupt the peace of nearby homes.

Marian Petruzzi, a long-time neighborhood watch leader, expressed her frustration over the park's new role, highlighting the impact of noise and light pollution on families living just yards away. "Residents never expected city leaders would arbitrarily turn this park into a sports complex," she lamented, emphasizing that the park's original intent was to serve the community quietly. Petruzzi's plea was underscored by her assertion that city officials have repeatedly ignored the concerns of the R Section residents, leaving them feeling marginalized and unheard.

The meeting saw a mix of voices, with some residents supporting the park's new use. Dr. Ryan Smith, a local business owner, defended the sports programs, stating they are vital for community engagement and youth development. "This is an asset to our community," he asserted, urging the council not to overlook the positive impact on families and local businesses.

However, the divide among residents was palpable. While some, like Yasadia Crawford, celebrated the opportunities provided by the sports programs, others felt their quality of life was being compromised. "Our section residents deserve peace and quiet, a good quality of life like everyone else in this city," Petruzzi insisted, calling for adherence to the park's stated operating hours.

As the discussions unfolded, it became clear that the council faces a challenging task: balancing the needs of families who cherish the park's activities with those who seek tranquility in their homes. Coach Jared Maxwell, who has dedicated years to youth sports, passionately argued for the importance of maintaining the park's lights and activities, emphasizing the role of sports in fostering leadership and community spirit among children.

The workshop highlighted a broader issue of community engagement and the need for city leaders to listen to all constituents. As the meeting concluded, the council was left with the weight of these conflicting perspectives, tasked with finding a solution that honors both the vibrancy of youth sports and the serenity of residential life. The outcome remains uncertain, but the voices of Palm Coast residents have made it clear: the future of Ralph Carter Park is a matter of deep community significance.