Allentown Zoning Board denies daycare and church applications for nonconforming building

In a recent meeting of the Allentown Zoning Hearing Board, significant discussions centered around the ongoing challenges related to zoning applications for a property that has been the subject of multiple hearings over the years. The board reviewed several past applications, highlighting the complexities of zoning regulations and the implications for community development.

The property in question has seen various proposals, including attempts to convert a former print shop into a daycare center and a church. Both applications were denied due to concerns about nonconforming uses and the lack of off-street parking, which is a critical issue in the already congested area. The board emphasized its responsibility to maintain the residential character of the neighborhood while also considering the need for reasonable development opportunities.

One notable application discussed was for the establishment of residential units on the second floor of the building. This proposal was met with mixed responses, as the board had previously denied similar requests. However, the board acknowledged the unique challenges posed by the building's configuration and the historical context of its use. The discussion underscored the delicate balance the board must strike between preserving neighborhood integrity and accommodating new residential needs.

The board also reviewed the permitted uses within the RMH zoning district, confirming that while some commercial uses are allowed by special exception, many others are not. This limitation has led to repeated denials for various applications, raising questions about the future viability of the property and its potential contributions to the community.

As the meeting concluded, the board's deliberations highlighted the ongoing tension between development aspirations and regulatory constraints. The decisions made in these hearings will have lasting implications for the property and the surrounding neighborhood, as the board continues to navigate the complexities of zoning laws in Allentown. The next steps will involve further evaluations of the proposed residential units and any new applications that may arise, as the community seeks to find a path forward that respects both its historical context and future growth.