Design concerns raised over gated community project on Turner Street

In a recent Planning Commission meeting held on March 11, 2025, in Allentown, Pennsylvania, city officials and developers engaged in a detailed discussion regarding the design and functionality of a proposed residential project. The meeting highlighted significant concerns about traffic flow, delivery logistics, and community accessibility, particularly in relation to the planned gated community structure.

One of the primary topics of concern was the management of package deliveries. Commission members raised questions about how delivery trucks, such as those from FedEx and UPS, would navigate the site, especially given the presence of an office intended to facilitate package acceptance. The design's current layout raised doubts about the efficiency and safety of trash collection, with concerns about garbage trucks needing to back out of tight spaces, potentially creating hazards for residents and disrupting the neighborhood.

Parking configurations also came under scrutiny. The proposed design includes parking stalls adjacent to sidewalks, which could impede pedestrian movement. Suggestions were made to either widen the sidewalks or adjust their placement to enhance safety and accessibility. The need for better connectivity within the property was emphasized, with some members advocating for the inclusion of steps and pathways to promote pedestrian flow.

The discussion also touched on the implications of having a gated community. Several commission members expressed skepticism about the necessity and practicality of a gate, particularly in a densely populated development. Concerns were raised about how visitors would access the property if no one was available to grant entry, potentially leading to traffic issues on surrounding roads. The idea of removing the gate to create a more open and accessible environment was proposed, with some members arguing that security could still be maintained through on-site staff.

In conclusion, the Planning Commission's meeting underscored the complexities involved in designing a residential project that balances security, accessibility, and community integration. As discussions continue, the commission will need to address these concerns to ensure that the development meets the needs of both future residents and the surrounding community. The next steps will likely involve revisiting the design plans to incorporate feedback and enhance the overall functionality of the project.