Councilman Starr criticized over costly lawsuit against street maintenance funding

During the recent Oxnard City Council meeting on April 15, 2025, significant tensions emerged surrounding a lawsuit initiated by Council Member Aaron Starr in 2023. The lawsuit, which questions the council's decision regarding street maintenance funds, has sparked controversy over its financial implications for the city.

Starr's legal action stems from his belief that the council should have sought voter approval before allocating these funds. However, Council Member Herrera criticized Starr for the millions in legal fees incurred by the city in opposing the lawsuit. Herrera claims that these costs are questionable and continue to escalate, forcing the city to rely on cash funding for street repairs. This situation raises concerns about the financial management of city resources and the impact of legal disputes on essential services.

Moreover, Herrera's comments included a call for the recall of Starr, linking it to Starr's support for Treasurer Molina, who recently had his duties reassigned to the chief of police. This political maneuvering highlights the ongoing conflicts within the council and raises questions about the motivations behind such actions. Notably, Herrera did not address the failed legal action against Molina, which resulted in a significant financial settlement for him.

The meeting also revealed potential conflicts of interest, as Herrera is perceived to have a close relationship with City Manager Alex Nguyen. This relationship has led to concerns about the impartiality of city officials and the influence of personal vendettas on council decisions. The call for an investigation into these matters underscores the need for transparency and accountability within the city's governance.

As the council navigates these complex issues, the implications for Oxnard's political landscape and financial health remain significant. The ongoing legal battles and internal conflicts could hinder the city's ability to effectively manage resources and serve its residents. The council's next steps will be crucial in addressing these challenges and restoring public trust.