Commissioners deny variance for McDonald's parking despite safety concerns and changing landscape

A heated discussion on parking variances took center stage at the Collierville Board of Zoning Appeals meeting on April 15, 2025, as members grappled with the evolving landscape of the restaurant industry and its implications for local businesses. The board faced a request from a restaurant seeking to increase its seating capacity, which raised concerns about the adequacy of parking spaces.

During the meeting, board members debated the potential for adding outdoor seating to alleviate parking issues. One member suggested that while the addition of 20 to 24 outdoor seats could help, it would still fall short of the required 45 additional parking spots. The conversation highlighted the challenges restaurants face in adapting to changing customer behaviors, particularly with the rise of delivery services like Uber Eats.

The crux of the discussion revolved around whether the current parking regulations adequately reflect the realities of modern dining. Several board members expressed frustration that the existing criteria for parking spaces, based on the number of seats, may not align with the current needs of the community. One member emphasized the need for legislative changes to address these discrepancies, arguing that the hardship faced by businesses stems from outdated regulations rather than the businesses themselves.

Ultimately, the board voted against the variance request, with members citing safety concerns and the belief that the issue should be addressed through broader regulatory reform rather than piecemeal approvals. The decision underscored a growing recognition that Collierville's zoning laws may need to evolve to support local businesses while ensuring community safety.

Looking ahead, the board plans to continue discussions on parking regulations and their impact on local commerce, with a commitment to finding solutions that benefit both businesses and residents. The next meeting is scheduled for May 15, where further discussions on variances and potential training opportunities for board members will take place.