Board reviews residential addition project amid guideline violations and contractor misrepresentations

The Lexington Board of Architectural Review convened on April 16, 2025, to address a contentious residential addition that has raised significant concerns among board members regarding compliance with established guidelines. The board discussed a proposed 20-foot addition to a home, which had initially been misrepresented as a gym in the site plans. Clarification revealed that the space would serve as a hobby room for quilting, not a gym, prompting discussions about the appropriateness of such an addition in a residential neighborhood.

Board members expressed apprehension about setting a precedent for future projects that might not adhere to zoning regulations. The staff recommended disapproval of the addition, citing that it did not meet several key guidelines. However, the board acknowledged the unique circumstances surrounding the project, including miscommunications with the contractor, and sought to find a way to move forward without enforcing a complete teardown of the addition.

During the meeting, members debated the potential for modifications that could bring the project closer to compliance. Suggestions included altering window designs to better fit the neighborhood's aesthetic. The board ultimately recognized the need for a motion that would allow the project to proceed while clearly stating that any future applications must adhere strictly to the guidelines.

As the board prepares to finalize their decision, they are tasked with crafting a motion that balances the unique situation of this project with the necessity of maintaining architectural standards in the community. The deadline for any revisions to the plans is set for May 3, 2025, as the board aims to ensure that future developments align with the character of Lexington's residential areas.