El Centro Council weighs extension of CRNR waste contract amidst discussions on service quality

The City of El Centro held a Special Council Meeting on April 15, 2025, to discuss significant developments regarding waste management services and the proposed extension of contracts with waste service providers. The meeting focused on the performance of current providers, Republic Services and CR&R, and the implications of extending their agreements.

The session began with a review of the existing contracts, particularly the proposed five-year extension for CR&R. Council members expressed concerns about the performance of both waste management companies, particularly in light of past issues with service reliability and equipment maintenance. A representative from Republic Services highlighted their commitment to maintaining service levels during the COVID-19 pandemic, asserting that they did not miss any pickups and have invested in their fleet, including the introduction of electric vehicles (EVs).

Discussion turned to the need for a new waste transfer facility, with CR&R representatives explaining the challenges they faced in securing property and permits for the project. They emphasized that the new facility would enhance service capabilities and contribute to the city's infrastructure. However, some council members expressed hesitation about extending the contract without seeing tangible progress on the facility.

The council debated the merits of continuing with CR&R versus exploring proposals from other companies, including Republic Services. Concerns were raised about the financial implications of switching providers, with estimates suggesting that the costs of a new request for proposals (RFP) could reach close to a million dollars. The council acknowledged that while both companies provide quality service, the decision to extend the contract with CR&R should be carefully considered.

Ultimately, the council discussed the potential for a five-year extension, contingent on CR&R meeting performance standards and completing the necessary infrastructure improvements. Some members voiced support for the extension, citing it as a strategic investment in the city’s future, while others remained cautious, advocating for further deliberation before making a decision.

The meeting concluded with a motion to accept the resolution for the five-year extension, reflecting a divided council on the best path forward for El Centro's waste management services. The council plans to revisit the discussion in future meetings to ensure that all concerns are adequately addressed before finalizing any agreements.