Ulster County legislators debate landfill site amid concerns for southern communities

In a heated Ulster County Legislative Session on April 15, 2025, lawmakers debated the contentious issue of landfill siting, reflecting deep divisions over waste management strategies in the region. The discussion centered around a proposed resolution that would postpone further studies on potential landfill sites, with some legislators advocating for a comprehensive review of the county's waste management needs before proceeding.

Legislator Roberts expressed frustration over the postponement, arguing that it demonstrated a lack of compassion for residents affected by the proposed landfill locations. He recalled past attempts to site a landfill in Plattekill and criticized the majority party for seemingly targeting the southern part of the county for waste disposal. "These people are talking about selling their houses," he stated, urging for a decisive vote to move forward.

Conversely, Legislator Green emphasized the need for a thorough examination of potential sites, cautioning against rushing into decisions that could lead to costly mistakes. He highlighted the importance of understanding the implications of siting a landfill in Ulster County, particularly given the area's groundwater concerns.

Legislator Maloney echoed these sentiments, suggesting that the county should explore alternative waste management technologies rather than focusing solely on landfill solutions. He pointed out that the ongoing discussions have wasted valuable time that could be spent on implementing more sustainable waste reduction strategies, such as composting and recycling initiatives.

The session also saw calls for a unified approach to waste management, with Legislator Nolan proposing that the county consider a resolution that encompasses all areas rather than singling out specific towns. He argued that a more collaborative effort could yield better results in addressing the county's waste challenges.

Legislator Hewitt, a lifelong environmentalist, underscored the need for innovative solutions to the garbage crisis, advocating for a zero-waste implementation plan that would involve all towns in the county. He stressed that the focus should be on reducing waste at its source rather than relying on landfills.

As the meeting concluded, it was clear that the issue of landfill siting remains a divisive topic among Ulster County legislators. The discussions highlighted the urgent need for a comprehensive waste management strategy that prioritizes environmental justice and community concerns. Moving forward, the legislature will need to balance the immediate pressures of waste disposal with long-term sustainability goals to effectively address the needs of its residents.