Board supports ADU project but seeks more detailing for aesthetic appeal

The Single Family Design Board meeting on April 21, 2025, focused on a proposed Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) project that aims to match the aesthetic of the existing front house. Board members discussed various aspects of the design, including color palettes, architectural details, and the overall massing of the structure.

Key discussions centered around the intention to maintain the current color of the front house while ensuring that the ADU complements it. The owner expressed plans for future renovations, including a potential second story on the front house, which could help screen the back unit. Board members raised concerns about the design's charm and character, noting that the proposed ADU lacks certain aesthetic features present in the front house, such as exposed rafters and decorative trim.

Several board members suggested that the project could benefit from additional landscaping to soften the appearance of the ADU, particularly given its proximity to neighboring properties. They also discussed the possibility of lowering the plate height of the second story to enhance the overall design and reduce its visual impact.

The board expressed a general willingness to support the project but emphasized the need for more detailed design elements that would add character to the ADU. Suggestions included incorporating wood details, decorative lighting, and a more cohesive window design. Ultimately, the board decided to continue the project indefinitely to the consent calendar, requesting further revisions that address their concerns while still aligning with the goal of matching the existing residence.

This meeting highlights the ongoing efforts in Santa Barbara to balance new housing developments with the preservation of neighborhood aesthetics and character.